Buried With Him: Grace's Answer to Cheap Grace
Every teacher of Romans meets the same question, and Paul meets it first. If the whole point is that we cannot earn it, then why not keep sinning so grace can keep covering the tab? Paul hears the question and practically flinches. How can we who died to sin still live in it?
What shall we say then? Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means! How can we who died to sin still live in it?
The answer in Romans 6 is not a new rule. It is a new identity, and Paul keeps the metaphor running until it lands: we were buried therefore with him by baptism into death.
You cannot sin your way into someone else's funeral
The argument in Romans 6 works by an unusual move. Paul does not answer the cheap-grace question with a more urgent commandment, which is what any of us would do. He answers with a fact about the believer's history. You do not get grace and then keep the old floor plan. You got into it through a door, and the door was a burial.
That is the part of the metaphor so easy to skate over. The Romans 6 passage does not say grace is a fresh coat of paint on the same house. It says the house is gone and a new one stands on the same lot. The person who sins is dead; the person who lives is a different person. Reason, will, desire, all of it has changed owners.
Why Paul can say death and mean life
The strangeness is deliberate. Nobody asks for a funeral at their own baptism. But Paul turns the burial into the thing worth announcing because of what came after it. If we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his.
So the sequence in Romans is: the wages of sin is death, and the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. Paul does not paper over the death. He takes the death that sin earned and hands it to the believer to live already. They pass through the penalty on the way to the gift. The old self is punished in the person of the Last Adam, and the new self opens its eyes on the other side of the grave.
The cheap version of grace keeps the old self and borrows a different account. The Romans version buries the old self and starts a new one, and the gift is not a waiver but a resurrection. The question Shall we continue in sin becomes not a rule to obey but a contradiction of everything the believer already died to. You cannot keep walking out of a grave you have already risen from. Romans 6:4 English - ESV